In the CartoonStock Caption Contest number 201, a man crawling through the desert comes upon a salesman with three water bottles—small, medium, and large—on a stand. The salesman speaks. The cartoonist is the enterprising P. C. Vey.
The rules of the monthly cash prize contest have not changed: Five dollars buys up to three entries. Real cash prizes are $500 for first place and $100 for each of five runners up. As of this writing, I've put $230 into the first forty-six pay-to-play contests and this forty-seventh challenge brings my total cash outlay up to $235. Having achieved runner-up status with three previous entries, I've collected $300 from CartoonStock, so I'm playing with the house's money, thank you very much. In fact, so few contestants enter that the odds may generally be considered favorable even for less-gifted caption writers. My three entries this round are shown below, above the break.
"Have as much as you want. It's a mirage." "This one costs a little more because it's vodka." "Me? I got here on a horse with no name." * * * "Sorry, I don't follow the rules of perspective." "Would you like to see the best value in Death Valley?" "Anything you don't finish here you can roll home." "What I really wanted was the Sea World concession." "Say, can you give me a lift home?" "By the way, nothing on credit." "Who'll start the bidding at $1,000?" "I'm not in it for the money. I do it for the schadenfreude." "If you have to ask, you can't afford it."
January 11, 2026 Update: The judging video has been posted. The cartoonist P. C. Vey chose my second caption (vodka) as the ninth in his top ten. They left off my period; no wonder it didn't win. From the regular judges, I got the usual crickets.
The Judges Deliberate
January 17, 2026 Update:The Winner
In his caption contest commentary, Lawrence Wood briefly mentioned the caption that P. C. Vey listed:
The third and final installment of Lászlo Roth's 1950s color cartoons from Esquire once again shows the artist mixing his media and playing with collage. Roth's approach is fairly uncommon and may have been an attempt to define a distinctive visual style for himself. Once again, Jeff Nelson has provided the images.
"Darling, may I drag you home?" Lászlo Roth Esquire, September 1955, page 89
Image courtesy of Jeff Nelson
"Pop, can I have the camel tonight?" Lászlo Roth Esquire, June 1956, page 122
Image courtesy of Jeff Nelson
Camel Crossing Lászlo Roth Esquire, August 1956, page 60
Note: I offer my thanks once again to Jeff Nelson for furnishing us with the images of Lászlo Roth's cartoons from Esquire. This is the fifth blog post to benefit from his efforts.
I can't really object to using fake grass in the desert where water is so precious. But, while I wouldn't want to put any waterfowl at risk, perhaps I can still object purely on esthetic grounds to the fake swans.
Note: This one looks like an unpublished rough. If there is a published version out there somewhere and you know where to find it, drop me a line.
The New Yorker's former art editor and cartoon editor Lee Lorenz is quite prolific, so there must be a lot of his work in circulation. If you have an example or two for the blog, please let me know.
January 23, 2017 Update: I voted for the second caption.
January 30, 2017 Update: Winning Caption
Note: Last week cartoonist Tom Chitty took to the stormy waters of New York Harbor and caught the Donald Trump wave. My caption was not Presidential. Set sail for Contest #551. Then enjoy your midnight at the oasis with more Attempted Bloggery posts about Robert Leighton. If you've ever been through the desert on a horse with no name, it will feel good to look at these cartoons.
Here is my entry in the New Yorker Cartoon Caption Contest #547 for November 28, 2016. The drawing is by Frank Cotham.
"I'm a sucker for parades."
What was I thinking? I had a few other ideas...
"She's half a beat off." [after Peter Arno] "I feel as if we're part of something." "I'd follow her anywhere." "This is so much better than chasing that oasis!" "I don't think she knows where she's going either."
I just wasn't meant to write this week's caption—or even to steal it. It's a good thing New Yorker cartoon editor Bob Mankoff was able to do much better in finding twelve semifinalists as informed by the crowdsourced rankings:
Here is my entry in the New Yorker Cartoon Caption Contest #487 for August 31, 2015. The drawing is by Michael Crawford.
"I'm the sole survivor of the pub crawl."
I think I was wise not to submit this one:
"Have you seen a horse with no name?"
An explanation for those who don't remember:
"A Horse with No Name" (1971)
Performed by America
Music and lyrics by Dewey Bunnell
September 7, 2015 Update:The Finalists
September 21, 2015 Update: Winning Caption
Note: Last week, Julia Suits brought a pet along to a Viking battle. Unfortunately, my caption was not housebroken. See the unHaralded results of Contest #486.
Attempted Bloggery's posts about cartoonist Michael Crawford now include an account of a recent gallery opening where your blogger was in attendance.
Here is my entry for the New Yorker Cartoon Caption Contest #424 for April 21, 2014. The drawing is provided by Tom Cheney and the caption is by me.
"I still say we should do the laundry at my mother's."
Here are a few other captions I came up with that I didn't use:
"Next time, hallucinate a refrigerator." "The good news is we don't need a dryer." "Maybe this is your idea of an oasis." "Good news. It's eco-friendly." "We're only forty miles from the nearest detergent."
April 28, 2014 Update: The Finalists
May 12, 2014 Update: Winning Caption
Note: Last week in Contest #423, some poor guy was abducted by his bathtub and the best caption I could come up with was this.
I'm fond of saying that Tom Cheney gives me more trouble than any other cartoonist in the caption contest, but the truth is they all give me trouble. Previous posts on Mr. Cheney are to be found here in the archives.