Monday, May 12, 2025

Robert Day: The Trouble With Harry

An original Robert Day cartoon that appeared in The New Yorker in October of 1961 was sold at Heritage Auctions on May 2. Heritage's caption is not as tightly worded as the published one; possibly the auction house copied it from somewhere on the artwork in Day's hand. Or it could be just sloppy transcription as the auction house got the date of the issue wrong too. Day's drawing takes us to a Manhattan construction site where things just aren't going well.

"Look, Harry, you bumped into the subway again!"
Published as
"Watch it, Harry! You've hit the subway again!"
Robert Day
Original art
The New Yorker,
 October 14, 1961, p. 48


Day produced a fine composition here. Way up above on the right, a bishop's crook lamppost indicates where street level is. Down below, our eye is skillfully directed from left to right. The construction site is convincingly rendered so that we are all the more surprised to see what the crane has excavated. The worried expressions of the construction crew contrast nicely with the obliviousness of the seasoned subway riders. We can enjoy the laugh knowing no one has been hurt—or even mildly disturbed.

Now, in order to ascertain Day's original caption, I'd prefer to see here not the matte, but whatever may be concealed underneath:
"Look, Harry, you bumped into the subway again!"
Published as 
"Watch it, Harry! You've hit the subway again!"
Robert Day
Matted original art
The New Yorker,
 October 14, 1961, p. 48


Robert Day
Heritage Auctions sale of May 2, 2025


Robert Day
Heritage Auctions item description

[End of Heritage Auctions listing]

Here's how this cartoon first appeared in print:

"Watch it, Harry! You've hit the subway again!"
Robert Day
The New Yorker, October 14, 1961, p. 48


"Watch it, Harry! You've hit the subway again!"
Robert Day
Original art
The New Yorker,
 October 14, 1961, p. 48

With a cartoon by Robert Day




04938

No comments:

Post a Comment